Trey believes he has found his purpose in life, to help deconstruct the faith of the victims of Christian brainwashing and to belittle those who promote the faith in an unseen creator. Showing off his impressive knowledge of science and disdain for the superstitious, he becomes an internet rock star. His chance encounter with Jeweli leaves him yearning for something more in life. His aspirations of a romantic conquest take a hit when he discovers that the woman who stole his heart is a devoted member of that subsection of culture he loves to mock. They both step out of their comfort zone when he challenges her to show him God.